"Middle-aged women with waists over 35 inches have a 30% higher risk of early death," reports the Mail Online.
Researchers in the US followed more than 156,000 women aged around 60, from 1993 to 1998 up to 2017. They measured their waist circumference and body mass index (BMI) at the start of the study. Over the next couple of decades, they recorded how many women died.
The study found that waist measurement was more closely linked to women's risk of death than BMI alone. This may be because a higher waist circumference suggests higher levels of fat stored around the organs. Fat around the abdominal organs may affect metabolism and put people at risk of diabetes.
We recently reported that women who had a higher percentage of fat around their trunk were more likely to have a heart attack or stroke than women who had more fat on their legs, but less around their upper body. This latest study seems to support that theory.
Where did the story come from?
The study was carried out by researchers from the University of Iowa, Kaiser Permanente health insurers, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, University of California, City of Hope National Medical Center and Harvard Medical School. It was funded by the US National Institutes of Health and the US Department of Health and Human Services. The study was published in the peer-reviewed journal JAMA Network Open, which is free to read online.
The Mail Online article says that the study "casts doubt on the validity" of the BMI as a useful marker for overweight and obesity, saying that it shows BMI does not differentiate between muscle and fat. While that is true, this has been known for some time.
The NHS recommends that people check their waist measurement as well as their BMI.
What kind of research was this?
This was a cohort study. Cohort studies are useful for looking at the links between risk factors (such as body mass index or "BMI" and waist measurement) and outcomes (such as mortality). However, they cannot prove that 1 risk factor directly causes an outcome, because other factors may be involved.
What did the research involve?
Researchers recruited women aged on average 62 years, between 1993 and 1998. The women had their weight and height measured to calculate their BMI, and their waists measured. Measurements were taken by trained staff. Women were also asked to fill in questionnaires about their diet, lifestyle and background.
The women were followed up until 2017. Researchers looked at whether they died of any cause, and also at deaths from cardiovascular disease or cancer. They excluded women who had a very low BMI (under 18.5) or who died within the first 3 years of the study, ending up with 156,624 participants.
They compared the risk of death for women in 6 categories:
- normal BMI (18.5 to 24.9) with normal waist measurement (88cm or less)
- normal BMI with high waist measurement (more than 88cm)
- overweight BMI (25 to 29.9) with normal waist measurement
- overweight BMI with high waist measurement
- obese BMI (30 or above) with normal waist measurement
- obese BMI with high waist measurement
They took account of other confounding factors including age, ethnic background, education level, income, smoking, physical activity, alcohol, diet quality and use of hormones (such as HRT or the contraceptive pill).
What were the basic results?
During the 2 decades of the study, 43,838 of the 156,624 women died. Of these, 29.6% died of cardiovascular disease, 27% from cancer and 43.4% from other causes.
Compared to women with normal BMI and normal waist measurement, women with high waist measurements were more likely to have died, regardless of their BMI. Researchers found:
- women with normal BMI and high waist measurement were 31% more likely to have died (hazard ratio (HR) 1.31, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.20 to 1.42)
- women with overweight BMI and high waist measurement were 16% more likely to have died (HR 1.16, 95% CI 1.13 to 1.20)
- women with obese BMI and high waist measurement were 30% more likely to have died (HR 1.30, 95% CI 1.27 to 1.34)
Women who were overweight or obese with normal waist measurement were no more likely to have died than women with normal BMI and normal waist measurement.
How did the researchers interpret the results?
The researchers said they had performed "the largest study with the longest follow-up period investigating the association of normal-weight central obesity [high waist measurement] with all-cause and CVD [cardiovascular disease] mortality and the first study to report the association of normal weight central obesity with cancer mortality".
They said: "Our results highlight the inability of BMI alone to distinguish body shape or body fat distribution… and the importance of measuring central obesity even among people with normal weight."
The study adds to evidence that how fat is stored and where it is stored may be as important as how much you weigh, in terms of effects on your health.
It's interesting that the study found women of normal body mass index (BMI) with high waist measurement had a higher risk than women who were overweight with high waist measurement. It's possible this could reflect more muscle mass among the women classed by BMI as overweight, or that women who were overweight tended to carry more weight on their hips compared to around their waist. But because this is an observational study, we do not know what is really behind the differences in risk.
The study found that few women had normal BMI with high waist measurement (1,390, 0.9% of total), and few women with obese BMI had normal waist measurement (4,957, 3.2% of total), so the figures relating to these groups need to be taken with caution.
There are other limitations to be aware of. The study only included women who had been through the menopause, so may not apply to women who have not, or to men. Waist measurement is not a direct measurement of how much fat is stored around the trunk – we would need body scan measurements to know for sure. Also, only measurements from the start of the study were used, so we do not know what the effects might be of changing BMI and waist measurement over time.
The waist measurement that the study authors took as the top end of "normal", 88cm, is higher than that at which the NHS says women should consider losing weight. The NHS says women should try to lose weight if your waist is more than 80cm and that women with a waist measurement of 88cm are at very high risk of developing conditions such as diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
Read more about why your waist size can be important.
Analysis by Bazian
Edited by NHS Website
Links to the headlines
Mail Online, 24 July 2019
Links to the science
JAMA Network Open. Published online 24 July 2019