Seasonal affective disorder 'may be a myth', study argues

Behind the Headlines

Friday January 22 2016

The idea behind SAD is lack of sunlight makes people depressed

Winter blues or just the blues?

"Stop blaming SAD for your bad mood – it doesn't exist! Seasonal changes have 'NO effect on depression,'' the Daily Mail reports.

Seasonal affective disorder (SAD) is described as a type of seasonal depression that may partly be triggered by reduced exposure to sunlight. This, in turn, can affect mood in a number of ways.

In this study, researchers took data from a telephone survey of around 35,000 people to see if season, latitude and sunlight exposure had a significant association with reported symptoms of depression. They did not find an association.

So does this mean SAD is a "myth", as some headlines claim? Not necessarily. A telephone survey is a very blunt tool and is no substitute for a face-to-face diagnosis by a trained clinician.

There is also, to some extent, a stigma attached to mental health problems, meaning some participants may not have provided entirely truthful answers. 

The important thing is if you are feeling depressed, whatever the time of year, seek medical advice from your GP.

SAD can be treated in the same way as depression, with talking therapies and medication. Some people have also reported benefiting from light box therapy, though the weight of evidence supporting this is relatively limited.  

Where did the story come from?

The study was carried out by researchers from Auburn University at Montgomery. No funding source or conflicts of interest were reported.

It was published in the peer-reviewed journal Clinical Psychological Science.

As is often the case, a single dissenting opinion has been overstated in the media as a change in expert consensus opinion.

SAD is recognised by bodies such as the Royal College of Psychiatrists and is included as a diagnosis in the American Psychiatric manual DSM-5.

Causes are likely to be multifactorial, rather than the oversimplification that the condition is caused by a reduction in sunlight exposure. 

What kind of research was this?

This was a cross-sectional study investigating SAD and whether there is a genuine link between exposure to sunlight and depressive symptoms. A number of analyses were conducted to assess this.

This type of study is not able to prove or disprove cause and effect.  

What did the research involve?

The researchers administered the Behavioural Risk Factor Surveillance System telephone survey to a random selection of the population in the United States.

This survey assesses health behaviours and collects information about health risk behaviours, healthcare access, and preventative measures.

The findings were analysed in a number of ways to draw links between sunlight exposure and depressive symptoms, including:

  • relationship of season
  • latitude or season
  • sunlight exposure

All models also assessed the effect of the following confounding variables:

  • age
  • race/ethnicity
  • gender
  • educational level
  • marital status
  • employment status

Classification of depression was made using an adaptation of the Patient Health Questionnaire depression scale (PHQ-8), a validated tool used to screen for symptoms of depression and give a rough guide to severity. The question about suicide was removed.  

What were the basic results?

The researchers analysed the surveys of 34,294 people with an average age of 52 years. There were 1,754 participants who were depressed, according to the PHQ-8 depression scale.

The researchers conducted their statistical models and found no effect of season, latitude or sunlight exposure on reported symptoms of depression.  

How did the researchers interpret the results?

The researchers concluded that, "Depression was unrelated to latitude, season, or sunlight. Results do not support the validity of a seasonal modifier in major depression.

"The idea of seasonal depression may be strongly rooted in folk psychology, but it is not supported by objective data. Consideration should be given to discontinuing seasonal variation as a diagnostic modifier of major depression." 

Conclusion

This cross-sectional study investigated whether season, latitude and sunlight exposure are linked to depressive symptoms that can be experienced in SAD.

The researchers found these factors had no effect on the occurrence of depressive symptoms.

However, this study has a number of important limitations. Depression was not a clinical diagnosis – it was based on the participant's response to a questionnaire over the phone.

This presents problems, as some people may not have answered questions truthfully, and those with depression or SAD may not have answered the phone.

The Royal College of Psychiatrists says around 3% of people will experience significant winter depression. This can be managed in the same way as clinical depression, through self-help techniques, talking therapies, medication, and the use of light box treatments.

Some of the self-help methods they suggest are:

  • increasing natural sunlight exposure, such as walking outside during daylight hours
  • regular exercise – read more about exercising in winter
  • recognising it is common to put on weight from eating more in autumn and winter, although excessive weight gain may make you feel worse – get tips on ways to avoid winter weight gain
  • connecting with others for mental wellbeing – sleepiness, lack of motivation, and irritability can be problematic, but gaining support from family and friends may help you manage these symptoms

Analysis by Bazian. Edited by NHS Choices. Follow NHS Choices on TwitterJoin the Healthy Evidence forum.

Analysis by Bazian

Edited by NHS Choices

Links to the headlines

Stop blaming SAD for your bad mood - it doesn't exist! Seasonal changes have 'NO effect on depression'. Daily Mail, January 22 2016

Cheer up... seasonal depression exposed as a myth. The Times, January 22 2016 (subscription required)

You are just sad not SAD: Winter's blues is a total myth, according to an American study. The Sun, January 22 2016

Seasonal Affective Disorder is probably a myth, say psychologists. The Daily Telegraph, January 21 2016

SAD news: There's no such thing as seasonal affective disorder. Daily Express, January 21 2016

Links to the science

Traffanstedt MK, Mehta S, LoBello SG. Major Depression With Seasonal Variation - Is It a Valid Construct? Clinical Psychological Science. Published online January 19 2016

Ratings

How helpful is this page?

Average rating

Based on 7 ratings

All ratings

2  ratings
2  ratings
1  ratings
0  ratings
2  ratings

Add your rating

Depression and low mood

In this video, an expert describes the various levels of depression, the early warning signs and the treatments available.

Media last reviewed: 03/05/2016

Next review due: 03/05/2018

What is Behind the Headlines?

What is Behind the Headlines?

We give you the facts without the fiction. Professor Sir Muir Gray, founder of Behind the Headlines, explains more...

Seasonal affective disorder (SAD)

Read about SAD, a type of depression that occurs in a seasonal pattern and is particularly common during the winter

Your NHS Health Check

Millions of people have already had their free 'midlife MOT'. Find out why this health check-up is so important

10 winter illnesses

Some health problems are triggered or worsened by cold weather. Find out how to protect yourself this season

Winter blues?

How to spot the warning signs of winter depression and tips to beat it

Exercise for depression

Find out the benefits of exercise for depression, including how to get exercise on prescription