'My PSA test found cancer'

Guy Williams with his children

Prostate cancer survivor Guy Williams talks about the PSA test, being diagnosed with cancer and why he decided to have surgery to remove his prostate gland.

Having a prostate cancer test should have been a no-brainer for Guy. He was 51 and both his father and uncle have the disease. His age and a family history of prostate cancer put him in a higher risk group. 

But his first attempt to have the PSA test, a blood test which looks for the early signs of cancer, showed just how divided the medical community is on the usefulness of the test.

PSA (prostate-specific antigen) is a protein made by the prostate gland. Some of it will leak into your blood, depending on your age and the health of your prostate. A raised PSA level in your blood may mean you have prostate cancer.

On the one hand, the PSA test could save your life if it detects the early signs of cancer. However, on the other hand a wrong diagnosis  which is not uncommon  could lead to unnecessary anxiety and potentially life-changing treatment.

"My GP leant strongly towards me not having a test," says Guy, a secondary school drama teacher and a father of three. "He suggested the PSA test was not entirely reliable and talked me through its pros and cons.

"He was entirely professional and gave me material to read to help me make a decision." After mulling over his doctor's advice and reading more about the condition, Guy decided not to have the test.

Getting a second opinion

'I was worried about the side effects of having a prostatectomy, but at least you live.'

Guy Williams

"When I told my father, he hit the roof," he says. "He insisted that I go back to the surgery and have the test. A short while later I went back to see a different doctor at the surgery."

Because of Guy's family history, the second doctor felt he should have the PSA test. "I got the results back the next day," Guy says.

"The test showed that my PSA level was raised. The doctor said there could be several reasons for this so, to be on the safe side, he did another test."

When this came back again with a PSA reading higher than is probably normal in someone of his age, Guy was referred to a specialist for a physical examination. He was then referred for a biopsy, which involves analysing tissue samples taken from the prostate.

The biopsy confirmed that Guy had cancer. A surgeon advised him that the best treatment option would be to have his prostate gland completely removed, a procedure called a prostatectomy.

"I was trying to ask the right questions but I was overwhelmed by the whole situation," he says. "Although the diagnosis wasn't completely out of the blue, it still really knocked me."

Treatment for prostate cancer generally depends on how fast the cancer is growing, whether it has spread outside the prostate gland, and the person's age and general health.

But all treatments, whether it's a prostatectomy, radiotherapy or hormone therapy, carry the risk of significant side effects. These include loss of sexual desire, erectile dysfunction and urinary incontinence

There's not always a clear medical reason for choosing one type of treatment over another. The decision may be based on a person's values, needs and preferences.

Prostate surgery

Guy read up on all his options, received help from Macmillan Cancer Support and used Prostate Cancer UK's decision-making toolkit. This is one of several aids available online or as a hard copy designed to help men decide which treatment to go for.

"All my research was really helpful but by the end I felt I had too much information," says Guy. "The more I knew, the more difficult it was to make a decision. I wanted someone to tell me what to do."

Guy was advised by his surgeon that the best course of action would be to surgically remove his prostate gland. Concerned about the possible side effects of a prostatectomy, he asked for a second opinion.

"I put all of my questions, worries and concerns to the next consultant I saw," he says. "After considering my circumstances, he too recommended surgery. At the end of the day, you must put a certain amount of trust in the professionals. Ultimately, they're the experts.

"I was worried about the side effects of having a prostatectomy, but at least you live. On balance, that's what I wanted. In the end, it wasn't really a choice."

In May 2011, five months after having the PSA test, Guy went in for surgery at Brighton's Royal Sussex County Hospital.

"The surgery went well," says Guy. "The pain and the bladder control, the side effects of the operation, are now much better. Exhaustion is my main problem. After a day's teaching I'm totally knocked out."

Guy's prostate gland was analysed after it was removed and tests showed the cancer was more aggressive than previously thought.

"For me, surgery was the right thing to do," says Guy. "If it had not been for my dad encouraging me to get a second opinion on having the PSA test, I probably would never have known I had prostate cancer." 

Find out more about whether you should have a PSA test.

Page last reviewed: 20/07/2014

Next review due: 20/07/2016


How helpful is this page?

Average rating

Based on 33 ratings

All ratings

Add your rating


The 4 comments posted are personal views. Any information they give has not been checked and may not be accurate.

User924769 said on 04 December 2014

Can you balance this article with views from men who made the same choice and regret it due to the many side effects? Or perhaps the alternative choices and men who praise an alternative decision.

Report this content as offensive or unsuitable

Arda Elee said on 03 November 2012

This article is easily summed up. The patient did not make any decision other than to follow his doctors recommendation. This is not much help to other men who want help to make a decision.

Report this content as offensive or unsuitable

Brenz said on 28 April 2012

The information understood by this 'survivor' is reflective of the poor information and medical intervention bias of prostate detection and treatment.

The only long running blind trial (PIBOT) evaluating how effective radical prostectomy and other treatments has observed the ineffectiveness of this 'choice'

The survivor Guy Williams states that with a radical prosectomy 'at least you live'. This is poor advice and should not be published. Many men die after a radical prostatectomy. The cancer reappears in over 40% of patients, many of whom will die of cancer. This is a very similar rate to men who choose to do nothing.

Of course, surgeons may not see it in quote such factual terms. That is why nobody present figures, percentages, ratios for cancer patients (they often say people cannot undertand the numbers). A cynical view may be to point out the years of surgical training and expertise, justifying well paid jobs, may lead to a bias of medical praticitioners to intervene medically.

Report this content as offensive or unsuitable

Sergei5 said on 25 March 2012

It would be helpful for medical or scientific comment on articles written or quoting patient opinion. Unfortunately Guy is often wrong in his beliefs.
Cognitive dissonance created by choices of treatment leaves him assuming 'surgery was the right thing to do'. Nobody knows this. He could have had no treatment and no side effects and still be able to live a full life. He could have picked alternative treatments and had less side effects.
One in three men who have radical prostatectomy see cancer return. I wonder if anyone else would feel it was the right decision if this happens.
A balance of risk and the liklihood of an adverse outcome is what is really needed. This is not available on NHS choices, NICE guidelines, MacMilllan or Prostate Charity sites. You need to ask a doctor (why can't they just write is here?) or do some study yourself.

8 years since undergoing prostatectomy and still living with the life changing side effects. My regret is deep and regret was never mentioned by my team of experts.

Report this content as offensive or unsuitable

Prostate problems

Read about the most common prostate problems experienced by men during their lifetime

Prostate health

Every man has one, it's important to their sex life, yet few men know anything about their prostate or what can go wrong with it